Electrophysiology CINRE, hospital BORY
epCINRE / Daily Fluctuations in Brugada Pattern (Type 1)

Daily Fluctuations in Brugada Pattern (Type 1)

  • It is known that Brugada pattern (Type 1 or 2)
    • is unmasked on the ECG during a fever, and has circadian fluctuation.
    • Fever (elevated temperature) unmasks the Brugada pattern on the ECG,
      • for example, a patient has at a temperature:
      • 37°C normal ECG and at
      • 39°C has the Brugada pattern on the ECG.
  • Circadian fluctuation of the Brugada pattern means,
    • that the pattern appears and disappears on the ECG during the day, for example, a patient has
    • normal ECG at 8:00 AM and
    • at 4:00 PM has the Brugada pattern on the ECG.
  • Ajmaline test
    • is performed if the patient has normal ECG (or Brugada pattern Type 2)
    • and there is a high suspicion of Brugada syndrome based on the medical history,
      • for example, the patient had syncope and a family member suddenly died.
    • The Ajmaline test is used to unmask the Brugada pattern (Type 1) on the ECG.
      • Flecainide is also used in place of ajmaline.
  • From the above, it can be concluded that the diagnosis of the Brugada pattern on the ECG is underestimated.
    • On an occasional 12-lead ECG (e.g., during routine check-ups),
    • the Brugada pattern on the ECG may never be captured in a patient.
  • ECG Holter monitoring (24-hour) captures Brugada pattern (Type 1) in 20% of patients
    • who have normal ECG
    • and the Brugada pattern is unmasked only during the Ajmaline (Flecainide) test

  • The following study analyzes:
    • Circadian fluctuation of ECG Brugada pattern Type 1 during 24 hours
    • in patients with Brugada syndrome
    • using an ECG Holter monitor
      • 24-hour
      • 12-lead
Brugada ECG pattern or sign Type 1, fever induced brugada, drug induced brugada, fluctuations brugada

Prevalence of Type 1 Brugada ECG Pattern Evaluated by 12-Lead 24-Hour ECG Holter Monitoring

Study Results

  • According to the ECG Holter monitoring, the occurrence of Brugada pattern Type 1 (BrP-1) was defined as:
    • Persistent (persisting >85% over 24 hours)
    • Intermittent (persisting <85% over 24 hours)
    • Absent (not present at all over 24 hours)
  • 251 patients with Brugada syndrome (BrS)
    • 75 (30%) had spontaneous BrP-1 on the baseline ECG
      • 9 (12%) had persistent BrP-1 (ECG Holter monitoring)
      • 43 (57%) had intermittent BrP-1
      • 23 (31%) had absent BrP-1
    • 176 (70%) had drug-induced BrP-1 (by Ajmaline or Flecainide)
      • 35 (20%) had intermittent BrP-1
      • 141 (80%) had absent BrP-1
  • Circadian occurrence of BrP-1 and heart rate in 4 phases of the day:
    • 00:00 – 06:00: 7% (69±7/min.)
    • 06:00 – 12:00: 9% (63±13/min.)
    • 12:00 – 18:00: 52% (90±8/min.)
    • 18:00 – 24:00: 32% (82±11/min.)
  • ECG Holter monitoring captures the Brugada pattern in 20% of patients
    • who have the Brugada pattern unmasked by Ajmaline/Flecainide
    • and have normal baseline ECG
Brugada pattern Type 1 with Spontaneous Fluctuation in 24-hour holter monitoring


Brugada pattern sign type 1 fluctuation, Infographic Flow Chart

Patient Profile and Study Methodology

  • 251 patients with Brugada syndrome (BrS)
    • BrS was defined as Brugada pattern Type 1 (BrP-1) (spontaneous or induced).
      • 33 were symptomatic (syncope, sudden cardiac death reversal).
    • Aged 15-46 years (72% were male).
    • Enrolled between 2001-2013 (Italy),
    • followed for 38±26 months since enrollment.
    • Each patient had at least 1 ECG Holter recording
  • ECG Holter monitoring
    • was 24-hour and 12-lead
    • Leads were placed:
      • V1, V2 (2nd intercostal space)
      • V3, V4 (4th intercostal space)
      • V5, V6 (5th intercostal space - standard position)
  • Based on the Holter ECG recording, the burden of BrP-1 was determined as:
    • Persistent BrP-1 (persisting >85% over 24 hours)
    • Intermittent BrP-1 (persisting <85% over 24 hours)
    • Absent BrP-1 (not present at all over 24 hours)
ECG holter brugada pattern type 1 burden per day, persistent, intermittent, absent

Occurrence of Brugada pattern on ECG Holter

  • 251 patients with BrS (33 were symptomatic)
    • 75 (30%) had spontaneous BrP-1 (captured on baseline ECG)
      • 63 patients were asymptomatic
      • 11 had a history of syncope
      • 1 patient had a reversed sudden cardiac death
      • 6 patients (6/75) had BrP-1 captured only during fever
        • These patients did not have BrP-1 on ECG Holters or ECGs without fever
      • according to ECG Holter monitoring
        • 9 (12%) had persistent BrP-1
        • 43 (57%) had intermittent BrP-1
        • 23 (31%) had absent BrP-1
    • 176 (70%) had drug-induced BrP-1 (by Ajmaline/Flecainide)
      • 154 patients were asymptomatic
      • 21 had a history of syncope
      • according to ECG Holter monitoring
        • 35 (20%) had intermittent BrP-1
        • 141 (80%) had absent BrP-1
ecg holter brugada syndrome and patter type 1 burden per day

Occurrence of Brugada pattern and Symptomatology

  • 251 patients with Brugada syndrome
    • 33 symptomatic (syncope, aborted sudden cardiac death)
      • 12 had BrP-1 on ECG Holter monitoring
    • 218 asymptomatic
      • 75 had BrP-1 on ECG Holter monitoring
brugada syndrome symptoms, aborted sudden death, syncope

Circadian Fluctuation of Brugada pattern

  • The occurrence of Brugada pattern Type 1 (BrP-1) during the day (24 hours) was analyzed
    • BrP-1 occurs most frequently in patients during the 12:00 - 18:00 time period
  • Circadian fluctuation of BrP-1 and heart rate in 4 phases of the day:
    • 24:00 – 06:00: 7% (69±7/min.)
    • 06:00 – 12:00: 9% (63±13/min.)
    • 12:00 – 18:00: 52% (90±8/min.)
    • 18:00 – 24:00: 32% (82±11/min.)
Circadian fluctuation ECG brugada pattern type 1, coved type

Reference 1 - Brugada pattern ECG holter

Reference 2 - Brugada pattern ECG holter